Cupcakes and Cashmere

Homemade Pop-Tarts

May 10th, 2011

When I was little, I struggled with slumber parties. I loved the idea of sleeping away from home, curled up in blankets watching movies with friends, but I rarely made it through the night. Once everyone went to bed, I’d tiptoe to the phone and, in between muffled whimpers, I’d ask my dad to come pick me up. And he always did.

It wasn’t until later in elementary school that I discovered the benefits of not going home. Whereas our pantry was stocked with gems like All Bran and Cheerios, friends’ cupboards were filled with sugary treats that were acceptable to eat for breakfast. That’s when I first fell in love with Pop-Tarts.

Since then, they’ve lost a bit of their appeal as I find the pastry bland, the insides overly sweet and often times they’re stale. Yesterday I made my own, using this recipe in three variations (apricot, chocolate and cinnamon brown-sugar), and all of the thrills of childhood slumber parties came rushing back in the form of a simple pastry.





Advertisement

  • http://www.ciaochessa.com Chessa!

    I absolutely LOVE this post. We never really had anything fun like pop tarts (or anything else) in our home growing up except occasionally we’d get cool ranch (always cool ranch) doritos. I adore this idea bc even though it’s not technically “healthy” it’s definitely better than whatever it is that pop tarts in a box are. not to mention more fun! this is a great idea for something to make with kids. I’m going to save it:)

  • Nicole Andrade

    Hi Emily!!!
    I’m a brazilian reader… I like so much the way that you keep your blog, combining food, fashion, simple things that make our lifes happier!!!
    Thanks for all tips!!!!
    XOXO

  • http://www.littleredbook-thatshaute.blogspot.com Little Red Book

    Amazing! And it doesn’t seem that hard to make.

    http://www.littlerebook-thatshaute.blogspot.com

  • http://none mk

    oh dang! i never thought homemade pop tarts existed, lol. never ever crossed my mind. i bet your version is 100x better

  • http://sweetandsassy-sherry.blogspot.com Sherry

    Oh gosh I used to INHALE pop tarts!! I haven’t had them in years though! Will definitely have to try this recipe out!!

    http://sweetandsassy-sherry.blogspot.com/

  • http://level20wife.blogspot.com Hilary

    Wow, these look like a major upgrade from store bought pop tarts. I want to try them out!

    Hilary
    Level20Wife.blogspot.com

  • http://www.therosiestcheeks.blogspot.com RoseyCheeks

    These are truly made to perfection! They look beautiful and delicious!

  • http://www.angelamatina.com Matina

    homemade pop tarts?! yay!

  • http://justbreathe18.blogspot.com/ shea nichole

    No you didn’t ;) I’m gonna have to make some pop-tarts now!!! :)

  • http://www.ladylovebelle.com Belle

    How fantastic! I think I might try these this weekend : ) I hope they turn out as well as yours did!

  • http://www.jessicajanuary.com january

    incredible! i need to try these!!!

    january, x
    jessicajanuary.com

  • http://insidethebelljar.blogspot.com Han

    These are going to destroy my summer diet, but thank you!!

    http://insidethebelljar.blogspot.com/

  • Beth

    Hi Emily! What a great post – as an elementary age girl, I also was “victim” to a cabinet full of Chex, but my girlfriend Rachelle always had Poptarts (chocolate). I’m sure she wondered why I never wanted to have the sleepover at my house!

  • http://sharkjumping.wordpress.com Marni

    Outstanding!!! I also love the pop of yellow today even though it’s not my color.

  • Claire

    Those look so good! How do you think of these things?!

    http://www.cheetahglitter.com

  • http://mustachebrigade.tumblr.com Tori

    My very first sleepover I was so excited but too anxious to sleep and I wanted to go home. Luckily, my friend grabbed a package of mini pop-tarts (ahhh the 90s) and we munched on those tasty treats and giggled until I was comfortable enough to sleep. So funny you had a similar experience of poptarts and sleepovers!

  • http://fashionfittingroom.blogspot.com Brandis

    I am inspired!

    fashionfittingroom.blogspot.com

  • http://victoriadiazs.wordpress.com/ victoria

    that looks so yummy! :O so gonna try it!!
    http://victoriadiazs.wordpress.com/

  • http://www.bluebonnetsforsal.com Sallie Lewis

    Those look SO scrumptious! Thanks for all your amazing culinary inspiration haha =)

    http://www.bluebonnetsforsal.com

  • http://www.thedressdiaries.blogspot.com Krystena

    I am a self proclaimed horrible cook but these looked so good I had to give them a try.. and they turned out perfectly! SO yummy thanks for the inspiring recipes :)

  • http://hannahjholmes.blogspot.com Hannah

    Homemade pop tarts, eh? Nifty!

  • http://vanityandvices.blogspot.com/ Ivana Tay

    You are always so inspirational.

    Food and fashion anyone?

    http://vanityandvices.blogspot.com/

  • http://projectjarrett.blogspot.com/ Lindsey

    Love this idea! I will have to give this a try very soon.

  • http://justfinebaby.blogspot.com/ Cicily

    Just made them. I used raspberry jam and they were awesome! we always have treats while watching TV on Saturday nights before bed, and these were perfect for me and the three kids!

  • http://pixelsinatree.blogspot.com Ricci

    OH gosh, they look so delicious I want to stand up and make them right now. I know what i am going to do this evening while watching my favorite detective series. <3

  • http://www.thebudgetbabe.com The Budget Babe

    ha i think our parents would get along. i don’t think i tasted a pop tart until college! :)

  • http://www.wastedwardrobe.net Midge

    Can you teach a class for us unrefined ladies please? I would sign up in a heartbeat.
    WastedWardrobe.net

  • http://alongtheshorestyle.blogspot.com Rebecca

    I MUST try this!

  • http://brightmitten.blogspot.com Nic

    I can totally relate to the childhood bond with Pop-Tarts! These do indeed look lovelier than what I remember–much more grown up. Yum!

  • http://www.youwedding.net/ Yoyo

    I like everything in this blog :) ))

  • http://www.kusadasi.tv kusadasi

    Those look so good! How do you think of these things?!

    http://www.acaiberryforsale.org/
    http://www.hepatit.com/en/

    How fantastic! I think I might try these this weekend : ) I hope they turn out as well as yours did!

  • cenessia

    Looks great I have been trying to find ways to use nuetella because my sis is obsessed with it.

  • Eliza M

    I have recently fallen in love with Pop Tarts, after initially finding them way to sweet and ‘fake-tasting’ I have grown to adore them but I can’t help thinking – this is too simple, I should be making my own! After a quick Google yours was the first to come up and I am on my way home to get baking these little beauties! Might I ask what is the best homemade filling?

    P.S. Your food photography skills are gorgeous! I want to gobble it all up – computer mouse and all!